
Why Can’t Science Understand Buddhist Meditation?
In this short article, I, a neuropsychologist and Dzogchen practitioner, explain, using the example of mental energy, why £5 bn in research over 50 years has brought very little scientific insight into the benefits of meditation and mindfulness. For decades, I’ve been looking at meditation and mindfulness from a scientific perspective.
Many of the ‘big’ problems in the psychological sciences are the fundamental pillars of how humans experience the world. Starting with consciousness and cascading down to mental energy, mental presence, emotional regulation, non-dual awareness and even more mundane concepts like effective prioritisation and procrastination, we psychologists have very little understanding of what they are and how they work. Conversely, the theoretical frameworks of non-dual Buddhism privilege an effective understanding of mental processes and encourage observation and transformation of said phenomena. Contemplative science has collected some useful data on the possible effects of meditation on physiological and psychological processes, sometimes mapped onto brain anatomy. However, we have made almost no progress in harnessing meditation and mindfulness practices for the collective good of humankind.
Meditation can change brain size, but not in one direction
With great fanfares, the Mindfulness Revolution exported Western interpretations of ancient spiritual practices from Asia into every walk of modern life, including among our politicians. The enthusiasm for a low-cost panacea at a time of declining mental health proved irresistible to governments, educationalists, the military and mega corporations. Scientists frequently abandoned the normal rules of the scientific method in a headlong rush to prove the anecdotal claims of elite Western academics, often with almost no meaningful experience of meditation or Buddhism. Surveying the scientific history of mindfulness and meditation, it’s clear that science followed the prompts of politicians, business leaders, and public health officials.
Of the 30,000 peer-reviewed studies that consider the benefits of meditation and mindfulness, almost none have attempted to understand Buddhist meditation on its own terms, rather, they appear to follow the unreplicated preliminary claims of academics who came into contact with meditation or Eastern religious traditions. Seen from a distance, the cause of this problem is simple. While the scientific method, when executed correctly, is pure, it is only a measurement system. Science is something very different, it is the management, belief in and interpretation of the results of the scientific method, data. However reliable, objective and replicated data, has almost never been harvested to objectively demonstrate how meditation or mindfulness works. That is one reason why almost all scientifically reliable, peer-reviewed mindfulness and meditation studies rarely indicate effect sizes significantly above placebo.
Let me explain the problem using the concept of mental energy. I recently gave a presentation to a group of experienced meditators and asked them what the greatest non-spiritual benefits they regularly get from meditation are. Based on a straw poll, most mentioned mental energy in some form (increased motivation, focus, clarity or concentration). Professionally, I work regularly with undergrads and postgrads, supporting them to reach their goals. A common limitation in undergraduates is a reported lack of mental energy or an inability to direct existing mental energy into the desired activities.
When I look at the peer-reviewed literature, I find dozens of theories about what mental energy is and how it is generated and depleted, none of which, in my opinion, are supported by reliable, replicated data. In reality, there is very little difference between how some ancient Greeks viewed mental energy or mental force and what we understand today. In the absence of reliable data, we psychologists attempt to use correlations or reverse engineering to create hypotheses which we then seek evidence to validate.
The lesson from the failed scientific attempts to understand human consciousness, or the mental processes used in meditation or the creation of mental energy, are not being learned. As a knowledge system, science only works if reliable data is gathered and interpreted correctly. Where reliable data is not available, more sophisticated, and probably transdisciplinary, methods of gathering data are likely necessary.
One insight I’ve gained from working with mental energy in psychological and Buddhist contexts is that, in complex areas of the mind, lived experience seems to deliver more meaningful data than the treadmill of partial scientific theories that dominates the literature on meditation and mental energy.